| Artist | Song | Popularity |
|---|
| Backstreet Boys | I Wanna Be With You | 1987 |
| Backstreet Boys | I Want It That Way | 21530 |
| Backstreet Boys | I Want It That Way (single version) | 1835 |
| Backstreet Boys | I'll Be There for You | 1992 |
| Backstreet Boys | I'll Never Break Your Heart | 1917 |
| Backstreet Boys | I’ll Be Home for Christmas | 587 |
| Backstreet Boys | If I Don't Have You | 1806 |
| Backstreet Boys | If I Knew Then | 1898 |
| Backstreet Boys | If You Want to Be Good Girl (Get Yourself a Bad Boy) | 1715 |
| Backstreet Boys | In a World Like This | 2132 |
| Backstreet Boys | Incomplete | 3472 |
| Backstreet Boys | Inconsolable | 2035 |
| Backstreet Boys | Intro | 1827 |
| Backstreet Boys | It's Gotta Be You | 2032 |
| Backstreet Boys | It's True | 1813 |
| Backstreet Boys | Just to Be Close to You | 2020 |
| Backstreet Boys | Just Want You to Know | 1848 |
| Backstreet Boys | Larger Than Life | 1256 |
| Backstreet Boys | Last Christmas | 625 |
| Backstreet Boys | Let's Have a Party | 1953 |
| Backstreet Boys | Like a Child | 1840 |
| Backstreet Boys | Lose It All | 2040 |
| Backstreet Boys | Love Somebody | 2221 |
| Backstreet Boys | Love Will Keep You Up All Night | 1804 |
| Backstreet Boys | Madeleine | 1848 |
| Backstreet Boys | Make Believe | 2165 |
| Backstreet Boys | Masquerade | 2001 |
| Backstreet Boys | More Than That | 1742 |
| Backstreet Boys | My Beautiful Woman | 1767 |
| Backstreet Boys | Never Gone | 1816 |